Avoid "Book Report Thinking"


If you asked me what my favorite type of fruit was, I could tell you in two ways.

Way #1: “Well, I like fruits with seeds. Sometimes they’re sweet; sometimes they’re sour. They have green leaves on the top. They’re pretty small, too.”

You might respond, “you mean a strawberry?”

Then I’d say yes, and you’d know my answer.

Or, I could tell you another way:

Way #2: “It’s a strawberry.”

This is the simple way to explain top-down communication. From the listener’s perspective, it is much easier to know what someone is talking about without having to follow a bunch of small, tiny details. But from the speaker’s perspective, it can feel uncomfortable, especially in work situations. In work situations, we often identify as a "thinker," or "analyst," and spend most of our time in the thought process or analysis before generating the answer. When it comes time to share our findings, it only feels natural to prioritize the details.

Details matter, of course, but people often don’t want to stick around for them unless you’ve laid out a compelling high-level vision for what the reader can expect. Almost all great stories begin with a high-level “hook” that creates suspense, gives context, or creates tension. Consider one of the best books of all time, Tale of Two Cities:

“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of light, it was the season of darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair.”

While there’s not much detail in this passage it invites you to go deeper into a story of oppositions (and one that is going to be well written too).

In business communication, the high-level context is the “so what?” – This is the information that tells the audience of your message and why they should pay attention. So don’t say, “Here is the financial information.” Say, “Given the recent challenges on our major product lines, this analysis will show the two major pressures that have put pressure on profitability.” When I give feedback to people on writing and presentations, I often just ask them, “What are you trying to say.” Whatever they tell me I then respond with, “Just say that!”

The tendency to want to share every last detail with your audience is something I like to call book report thinking, the tendency to treat work like a school book report where we are supposed to prove that we actually read the book. In real life, people don’t really care about how much work you’ve done or how you did it at all. They want useful information to enable them to help you or do their own job better.

So remember:

Start from the top.

Tell people why it matters.

If I had to give myself a bit of feedback on this newsletter issue, I probably should have started with: “This is a short reflection on how to communicate more clearly by starting with the most important things first,”

Guess I still have some learning to do.

Go Deeper

Watch the full video here explaining top-down communication:

video preview​

Paul Millerd

Freelancer, creator & writer

Read more from Paul Millerd

The first time I built a ghost deck was in Basic Consulting Readiness training at McKinsey, and it was uncomfortable. I had always been an "bottom-up" analyst. I didn't want to plan the high level. I wanted to dig into the data and figure it out as I went. That works when you are doing solo work, but isn't great when you are on a team. A ghost deck is a presentation you write before you do the analysis. It's simple: Each page gets a full-sentence title that states what you expect to find, and...

I ran 4-5 client workshops over the last few months, and all of them ended with one question: what does working with AI mean for your team? This is THE question right now Here's what I'm seeing inside organizations: Each person has their own approach; no one is sharing recipes Confusion about which models or platforms to use Top-down dictates without the leaders even knowing what they want. Lots of overconfidence with junior people shipping slop One prompt turns into a 30-page deck, and then...

In my workshops, I often use this slide: I'll then ask people to drop in the chat: "What percentile do you think 'high-performance' stands for if 100% is best? Answers flow in: 85% 95% 70% 60% 88% 99% It's almost always like this. I do something like this to show people that while we often have an exact number, it rarely matches what people are thinking or perceiving. This phenomenon is usually referred to as the illusion of transparency. If you can get more specific and exact, you will...