ChatGPT: better feedback than McKinsey consultant?
|
One of the challenges I've faced with teaching the skills in Think Like A Strategy Consultant is that the best way to learn them is by getting intensive feedback from others either learning these skills or who are good at applying them in their work. Many of the students taking the course are doing so independently. My average student is in a big company or consulting firm and is frustrated with their organization's lack of support and training. Despite that, they want to get better at these skills. Luckily, now, with AI, you can get instant feedback on your work, for less than $20 a month. I've been using it and have been really impressed with the latest models. Check out this example. Here's a slide I found from a recent McKinsey report: It's a solid slide. But can we do better? I pasted the image into ChatGPT and included the following prompt of principles from my course (steal this!): assume you are a very experienced strategy consultant, give feedback on the following slide. you want to make slides that are clear, compelling, and persuasive. you want to incorporate simple principles like having a title that communicates the "so what?" content that matches and backs up the title, charts that are simple and pass the "ten-second test" of being able to be understood by a large number of people, and overall slide content that is clear and not confusing. please give specific feedback and also offer suggestions on updated information or language to include: It gave some pretty awesome suggestions (here is the full response) and here are two that were pretty good: Feedback on the Title
Feedback on Supporting Quote
These tools are getting better fast. For the most motivated people, they are so helpful. Will they be able to instantly remake the slides in the future by themselves? Perhaps. But in the short term? It's the best time to learn on your own. Let me know if you try this. I'd love to feature a before and after slide from someone who gives this a shot. |
Paul Millerd
Freelancer, creator & writer
I ran 4-5 client workshops over the last few months, and all of them ended with one question: what does working with AI mean for your team? This is THE question right now Here's what I'm seeing inside organizations: Each person has their own approach; no one is sharing recipes Confusion about which models or platforms to use Top-down dictates without the leaders even knowing what they want. Lots of overconfidence with junior people shipping slop One prompt turns into a 30-page deck, and then...
In my workshops, I often use this slide: I'll then ask people to drop in the chat: "What percentile do you think 'high-performance' stands for if 100% is best? Answers flow in: 85% 95% 70% 60% 88% 99% It's almost always like this. I do something like this to show people that while we often have an exact number, it rarely matches what people are thinking or perceiving. This phenomenon is usually referred to as the illusion of transparency. If you can get more specific and exact, you will...
The latest version of Claude can create PowerPoint slides. So I gave it a challenge. Turn this "bad example" I use in my workshops into a good slide based on the principles I share on strategyU.co I gave it this simple prompt that took me no longer than ten seconds to write: Take this slide and take the lessons on slide design on strategyu.co and turn this into a compelling slide, improve the fonts, get to one single insight, match the title and content, and have the title be a clear takeaway...